
By Benjamin Cuaresma
MANILA, Philippines — A massive rally by thousands of Iglesia ni Cristo (INC) members that brought large sections of EDSA to a standstill on Tuesday has ignited questions over whether the country’s laws on public assemblies are being enforced equally—or selectively.
The demonstration, staged in support of embattled Senator Rodante Marcoleta, proceeded for several hours despite authorities acknowledging that organizers had not secured the permit required under Batas Pambansa Blg. 880, the Public Assembly Act.
Instead of dispersing the crowd, police negotiated with organizers while traffic on one of the country’s busiest highways collapsed, leaving thousands of commuters, workers, students and motorists stranded during the morning rush.
Only later in the day did the Quezon City government issue a permit authorizing the rally to continue on Wednesday along White Plains Avenue under specified conditions.
The sequence of events immediately raised a central question: Can a public assembly begin without a permit and later be legitimized through one issued after the gathering is already underway?
The Metropolitan Manila Development Authority confirmed that organizers did not coordinate with the agency before occupying major roads. Emergency traffic rerouting was implemented only after buses carrying participants blocked portions of EDSA, White Plains Avenue and the EDSA Carousel lane, resulting in hours of severe congestion across Metro Manila.
By late afternoon, the Philippine National Police estimated attendance at more than 14,000 participants.
Despite the lack of an initial permit, authorities chose what they described as “maximum tolerance,” arguing that forcibly dispersing thousands of demonstrators could have escalated into violence.
That explanation, however, has fueled public debate over consistency in law enforcement.
In previous demonstrations involving labor groups, transport organizations and other activist movements, permit issues have often resulted in dispersals, arrests or the filing of criminal complaints. Tuesday’s events have prompted renewed scrutiny over whether all groups are being treated under the same legal standard.
The PNP itself acknowledged the issue in a public statement, stressing that respect for the rule of law must be consistent and that no advocacy or organization should be considered beyond the reach of laws governing public assemblies.
Even so, the operational response appeared to differ from what many observers have seen in past protests.
The rally briefly turned confrontational when police attempted to clear buses obstructing traffic. Four individuals were arrested, including a bus driver accused of striking a police officer with his vehicle and another participant allegedly assaulting an officer. Police reported that three officers sustained injuries during the incident.
The demonstration was organized after the Office of the Ombudsman announced the filing of plunder and indirect bribery charges against Senator Marcoleta before the Sandiganbayan.
Prosecutors alleged that Marcoleta failed to disclose ₱75 million in campaign contributions during the 2025 elections. The senator has denied any wrongdoing, maintaining that the donations were received before the official campaign period and therefore did not fall within election reporting requirements.
The gathering also drew several political figures, including former congressman Mike Defensor, Batangas Representative Leandro Leviste and Senator Alan Peter Cayetano.
Beyond the political message, Tuesday’s events have shifted attention to a broader issue: whether the government applies the law uniformly regardless of the size, influence or identity of those involved.
As investigations continue and the second day of the rally proceeds under an approved permit, many are now asking whether this episode will become a benchmark for future public assemblies—or an exception that further fuels public skepticism about equal protection and equal enforcement under the law.
