
Paolo Panelo faces a formal demand for explanation after questioning the impartiality of tribunal members during the defense witness examination
By Benjamin Cuaresma
MANILA — The Senate impeachment court has ordered the issuance of a show-cause notice against lawyer Paolo Panelo, spokesperson for Vice President Sara Duterte, following his public accusations that several senator-judges were displaying bias while examining a defense witness.
The action came Friday, November 20, after Senator-judge Erwin Tulfo raised Panelo’s remarks before the tribunal at the opening of the 45th day of Duterte’s impeachment trial. Tulfo questioned the propriety of the Vice President’s spokesperson publicly criticizing members of the very court hearing her case.
Panelo’s comments stemmed from Thursday’s proceedings, when senator-judges Raffy Tulfo, Risa Hontiveros and Kiko Pangilinan questioned defense witness Rainer Dela Fuente, a former Anti-Money Laundering Council investigator.
In media interviews, Panelo accused the three senator-judges of acting like prosecutors by challenging the witness’s credibility. He argued that assessing and attacking a witness should be the prosecution’s responsibility, not that of the judges tasked with hearing both sides.
Panelo also appealed to Presiding Officer Francis Escudero to remind members of the tribunal to exercise restraint and avoid conduct that could appear to favor either side. He acknowledged that senators from both the majority and minority had at times engaged in questioning he considered partisan.
Tulfo, however, told the court that Panelo’s position as Duterte’s spokesperson made his public criticism of the senator-judges a matter requiring the tribunal’s attention. He stressed that although Panelo was not a party to the impeachment case, his role as the Vice President’s representative raised concerns about his comments on the court’s proceedings.
Escudero explained that Panelo was not covered by the impeachment court’s sub judice restriction, which governs public statements by parties and other individuals covered by the rule. However, the presiding officer pointed to the possible application of Rule 71 of the Rules of Court on contempt, under which the tribunal could exercise authority over conduct involving the court.
Tulfo then sought a formal order requiring Panelo to explain his statements. With no objection raised by the senator-judges, Escudero directed the Clerk of Court to issue the show-cause notice.
The order does not constitute a finding of contempt or establish that Panelo committed an offense. It requires him to account for his remarks before the court determines whether further action is warranted.
As of the publication of the reports, Panelo had not yet issued a response to the court’s action.
The development adds another point of contention to Duterte’s impeachment proceedings, which have increasingly featured disputes over the examination of witnesses, the interpretation of evidence and the conduct expected of those participating in the trial.
ia/xf
