
By Benjamin Cuaresma
MANILA — A consumer advocacy group and whistleblowers have accused officials of the San Jose del Monte (Bulacan) Water District (SJDMWD) of allowing a public utility to become a financial lifeline for PrimeWater Infrastructure Corp., alleging years of losses, regulatory failures and the use of government resources for obligations supposedly assigned to the private operator.
The allegations were contained in a 928-page complaint filed before the Office of the Ombudsman against SJDMWD officials and PrimeWater executives and owners, including former senator Manuel Villar Jr., former senator Cynthia Villar, and their children Paolo Villar, Sen. Mark Villar and Sen. Camille Villar.
Also named were PrimeWater executives Fe Rabancos, Lester Santos and Victor Canita.
The SJDMWD officials named in the complaint are board chairman Aurelio Jose Jr., vice chairman Armando de Los Reyes, secretary Jovita Vizmonte-Mateo, board member Leo Brigino, and general manager Loreto Limcolioc.
The water district officials face administrative complaints for grave misconduct, gross neglect of duty and conduct prejudicial to the best interest of the service.
At the center of the complaint is what the complainants described as the water district management’s failure to act on years of adverse findings by the Commission on Audit (COA).
They cited COA reports from 2018 through 2024 involving financial losses, incomplete asset records and alleged violations of contractual obligations.
Before PrimeWater assumed operations in May 2018, SJDMWD reported net income of P187.56 million in 2016 and P126.48 million in 2017, according to figures cited in the complaint.
The complainants said the financial performance deteriorated sharply after the joint venture took effect.
Net income reportedly fell to P53.6 million in 2018, plunged to P2.27 million in 2019, and turned into a P5.35-million net loss in 2020.
The figures formed part of the complainants’ argument that the joint venture failed to deliver the financial results expected from the arrangement.
The complainants also focused on the alleged failure of SJDMWD to establish a Rewards and Penalties Framework, which they said was expressly required under the joint venture agreement.
Without the mechanism, they alleged, the water district was effectively deprived of a contractual tool to impose financial penalties on PrimeWater for service failures.
The complaint said the deficiency persisted for six years, from 2018 to 2024, despite repeated COA observations.
The complainants further alleged that the water district failed to enforce leakage-control measures, resulting in more than P247 million in estimated lost revenue annually.
The complaint alleged that SJDMWD advanced public funds for expenses that were supposed to be PrimeWater’s responsibility under the joint venture agreement.
The amounts cited were P69.64 million as of December 31, 2023, and P59.98 million as of December 31, 2024.
These allegedly covered bulk water supply, continuing projects, emergency booster pumps and supplies.
The complainants argued that such expenditures effectively shifted financial burdens from the private partner to the public water district.
PrimeWater’s investment commitment also came under scrutiny.
According to the complaint, the company committed to invest P6.771 billion over 25 years under the joint venture.
But after seven years, the complainants said only about P748 million, or roughly 11 percent of the commitment, had been invested.
They cited the disparity as another indication of what they described as an imbalance in the joint venture arrangement.
The complaint also raised the issue of more than 1,400 pending water connection applications in 2024.
The complainants alleged that after PrimeWater failed to process the applications, SJDMWD used government funds and personnel to complete the installations.
PrimeWater, however, allegedly continued collecting the P1,915 connection application fee from consumers.
For the complainants, the episode illustrated what they described as a recurring pattern in which the public water district absorbed costs while the private operator continued to receive revenues.
The complainants are asking the Ombudsman to impose preventive suspension without pay on the SJDMWD officials named in the case.
They alleged that the officials abandoned their regulatory responsibilities and failed to protect consumers despite years of audit findings.
The complaint further claimed that the alleged failures contributed to water shortages that disrupted commerce, caused school class suspensions and affected hundreds of thousands of residents.
The accusations against the SJDMWD officials, the Villar family and PrimeWater executives remain allegations contained in the complaint and have yet to be established by the Ombudsman.
The filing now places the controversial water district joint venture under formal scrutiny, with the complainants asking investigators to determine whether public resources and regulatory authority were improperly used to benefit the private operator.
ia/xf
