
By Benjamin Cuaresma
The Supreme Court has called on the Ombudsman to formally file complaints and present evidence to support allegations of partiality, misconduct, and corruption involving an appellate court, stressing that serious accusations must undergo proper judicial processes.
In a statement responding to remarks made by the Ombudsman during the Senate Committee on Finance hearing on September 3, 2026, the Supreme Court said court proceedings at all levels must remain accountable to the public, as required by the Constitution.
The Court said it takes allegations of wrongdoing involving members of the judiciary seriously and acts on such complaints when they are formally filed, supported by evidence, and the judges or justices concerned are allowed to respond.
However, the Supreme Court said it cannot take action on broad accusations directed against an entire appellate court solely based on public statements.
It therefore urged the Ombudsman, or any concerned party, to pursue the appropriate legal process.
“We therefore invite the Ombudsman, or any concerned party, to file the proper complaint and submit supporting evidence,” the Court said.
Such a filing, it added, would enable the Court to establish the facts and, when warranted, exercise its disciplinary authority.
The Supreme Court also cited its recent unanimous ruling in In re Heydarian, Cendana, and Gadon, in which it affirmed the public’s constitutional right to freedom of expression, including the right to criticize courts and their decisions.
The Court noted that despite strong statements made against it in connection with one of its rulings, it upheld the respondents’ freedom of speech and declined to hold them in contempt.
The Supreme Court said it welcomes fair criticism of the judiciary but emphasized that allegations involving judicial misconduct should be brought before the proper forums, where they can be investigated and resolved based on evidence and established procedures.
ia/xf
