
Matibag Says Senators, Witnesses Not Covered by Parliamentary Immunity in Contested Proceeding
By Benjamin Cuaresma
MANILA — National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) Director Melvin Matibag has warned that senators and witnesses who participated in the June 4 Blue Ribbon Committee hearing conducted by the faction led by former Senate President Alan Peter Cayetano may face criminal and administrative liability, arguing that the proceeding did not enjoy the protections normally afforded to official Senate inquiries.
Speaking during a roundtable discussion with editors and reporters of the Philippine Daily Inquirer, Matibag said statements made during the hearing may not be covered by parliamentary immunity if the proceeding is ultimately deemed unauthorized or unofficial.
“Everything that they said there, including the allegations they made, may expose them to liability for libel or slander,” Matibag said.
The NBI chief, a former law school dean, also said senators who presided over or participated in the hearing could potentially face allegations of usurpation of authority and violations of Republic Act No. 6713, or the Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees.
The controversy stems from the escalating leadership dispute in the Senate following the emergence of a new majority bloc led by Senate President Sherwin Gatchalian.
On June 3, the Senate regained quorum after Senator Francis “Chiz” Escudero joined the Gatchalian-led bloc, giving it the support of 12 senators. The majority subsequently declared vacant several key Senate positions, including leadership posts in the Blue Ribbon Committee held by Senators Pia Cayetano and Rodante Marcoleta.
Despite the reorganization, the Cayetano faction proceeded with a separate Blue Ribbon hearing on June 4, where several witnesses claiming to be former couriers or “bagmen” linked to businessman and former congressman Zaldy Co appeared and testified.
The hearing was later suspended indefinitely following questions regarding the consistency and credibility of some testimonies.
The Armed Forces of the Philippines subsequently clarified that most of the witnesses presented as former Marines were no longer connected with the military. The Philippine Navy further disclosed that several had been dishonorably discharged, while others had never served in the Philippine Marines.
Former Senate President Franklin Drilon also questioned the validity of the proceeding, noting that it did not follow established Senate procedures and lacked the participation of an official committee secretariat responsible for recording and documenting hearings.
Former Surigao del Norte Representative Robert Ace Barbers likewise criticized the gathering, describing it as an “illegal assembly” and warning against the use of government facilities and resources for activities lacking official authorization.
The issue has added another layer to the growing institutional dispute within the Senate, where rival factions continue to contest the legitimacy of leadership positions, committee assignments, and investigative proceedings.
As legal and constitutional questions surrounding the June 4 hearing continue to mount, observers say the matter could ultimately test the limits of Senate authority and parliamentary privilege amid an unprecedented leadership impasse.
ia/xf
