
UP Law Dean Says Boycott Could Hand Senate Control to Gatchalian Bloc
By Benjamin Cuaresma
MANILA — All 22 senators who remain under the Senate’s jurisdiction should attend a special session that may be called by President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. to finally resolve the chamber’s month-long leadership dispute, a constitutional law expert said Sunday.
University of the Philippines College of Law Associate Dean Paolo Tamase said senators aligned with former Senate President Alan Peter Cayetano should abandon any plans to boycott a special session, warning that doing so could effectively cede control of the chamber to Acting Senate President Sherwin Gatchalian and his 12-member majority bloc.
“If the 10 refuse to attend and the 12 do, the majority bloc can insist on quorum and exercise the Senate’s powers,” Tamase said, citing the Avelino doctrine and prevailing constitutional interpretations recognizing the authority of the current majority.
According to Tamase, continued absence by the Cayetano bloc could place pressure on some of its members to join the majority in the interest of restoring a functioning Senate and ending weeks of legislative paralysis.
President Marcos has yet to issue a proclamation calling Congress into special session. However, Malacañang has indicated it would promptly act on any formal request from Gatchalian should the Senate seek presidential intervention.
The constitutional expert argued that a special session would provide the proper venue for senators to settle the leadership issue before the opening of the Second Regular Session of the 20th Congress and the President’s fifth State of the Nation Address (SONA) on July 27.
Tamara maintained that the Senate’s authority to elect its presiding officer is inseparable from its legislative powers and can therefore be exercised during a special session convened by the President.
“The Senate should not allow an almost two-month congressional break to prevent it from determining who legitimately leads the chamber,” he said.
The leadership conflict intensified after Senator Francis “Chiz” Escudero crossed over to the Gatchalian camp, giving the latter a 12-member majority and enabling the bloc to establish quorum before Congress adjourned sine die on June 3.
Gatchalian has since been recognized by Malacañang as the Senate’s acting leader, a position reinforced by statements from Palace officials who insist that Cayetano no longer commands majority support within the chamber.
Palace Press Officer and Presidential Communications Office Undersecretary Claire Castro said the continuing dispute threatens to delay key legislative priorities of the Marcos administration, including measures aimed at addressing rising fuel costs, economic concerns arising from tensions in the Middle East, and several priority bills targeted for passage before the President’s SONA.
Among the administration’s legislative priorities are proposals to abolish the travel tax and strengthen measures against political dynasties.
Tamase, however, rejected suggestions that Malacañang’s public recognition of Gatchalian constituted executive interference in Senate affairs.
“It only becomes unconstitutional when one branch imposes its will on another. Expressing a political preference remains part of democratic politics,” he said.
He added that leadership contests in elected institutions are ultimately settled through political support rather than legal arguments.
“The Constitution and Senate rules exist not to determine political winners, but to ensure orderly transitions, protect minority rights, and prevent a minority from claiming majority authority,” Tamase said.
With the Senate leadership battle showing no signs of immediate resolution, observers say a special session may ultimately become the decisive forum for determining who legitimately holds the Senate presidency and whether the chamber can return to its legislative work ahead of the President’s annual address.
ia/xf
