
By Benjamin Cuaresma
MANILA — The leadership dispute in the Senate escalated Thursday as former Senate President Pro Tempore and newly aligned Majority Bloc member Senator Tito Sotto questioned the legitimacy of a Blue Ribbon Committee hearing being conducted under Senator Pia Cayetano, insisting that the panel was no longer under her authority following the leadership reorganization in the chamber.
Sotto maintained that the Blue Ribbon Committee is now headed by Senator Erwin Tulfo, who was elected during the Senate’s reorganization, making any proceeding conducted under Cayetano’s chairmanship “illegal” and unofficial.
“Ang Blue Ribbon Committee chairman ngayon ay si Senator Erwin Tulfo na. Iyon ang hinalal namin kahapon. Lahat ng ibang puwesto ay bakante na maliban doon sa mga nahalal kahapon,” Sotto said.
He added that while senators remain free to hold meetings, such gatherings no longer carry official authority.
“Meeting lang iyan. Mga senador naman sila at gusto nilang magpulong. Pero hindi iyan official,” he stressed.
The remarks came after Cayetano convened a hearing involving former military personnel linked to the Senate’s ongoing flood-control investigation, despite the ongoing dispute over the chamber’s leadership structure.
Cayetano, however, rejected claims that her authority had already ceased, arguing that Senate rules clearly state that officials remain in office until their duly elected successors assume the position.
Quoting Section 10 of the Senate Rules, Cayetano emphasized that the term of office of Senate officials ends only when successors have been properly elected.
“Nahalal na po ba ang kapalit ko? Siya mismo ang nagsabi na naghihintay pa sila ng 13. So ladies and gentlemen, we will continue to function,” Cayetano declared.
She accused her critics of sowing confusion and undermining legitimate Senate proceedings, saying her camp would continue defending what she described as constitutional and procedural truth.
“Hindi kami kapit-tuko. Pero ipaglalaban namin para sa Pilipino ang Konstitusyon at ang katotohanan,” she said.
Cayetano also defended her decision to designate Senator Dante Marcoleta as head of a Blue Ribbon subcommittee tasked with pursuing the inquiry into alleged irregularities in flood-control projects.
Reading from an official memorandum she signed before the leadership shake-up, Cayetano cited Section 20 of the Senate Rules of Procedure Governing Inquiries in Aid of Legislation, which authorizes committee chairpersons to create subcommittees and delegate investigative powers.
“The Chairman of a committee may create subcommittees as may be deemed necessary for the purpose of performing all acts which the committee as a whole is authorized to do,” she quoted.
According to Cayetano, the subcommittee’s authority remains valid and should not be questioned merely because of the political conflict now gripping the Senate.
The conflicting interpretations of Senate rules have further exposed the widening rift between rival factions in the chamber following the dramatic leadership showdown that resulted in the installation of a new Senate leadership bloc.
While Sotto and the majority faction insist that committee positions were effectively vacated following the reorganization, Cayetano and her allies argue that procedural rules protect incumbent officials until successors are formally elected and recognized.
With both camps invoking Senate rules to justify their positions, the dispute is expected to trigger further institutional and legal challenges over the validity of committee actions, investigations, and resolutions undertaken amid the ongoing power struggle.
ia/xf
