
Sourced online by Tracy Cabrera
MANILA — Contrary to claims by the minority bloc led by erstwhile Senate President Alan Peter Cayetano that there is no basis to consider Wednesday’s Senate session as legal, there is in fact an earlier court ruling that the Senate’s quorum of 12 senators is legal.
Based on the Avelino ruling of 1949, it was decided that 12 senators are enough to create a quorum, so Senator Francis ‘Chiz’ Escudero’s appearance at the plenary on Wednesday, June 3, broke the impasse in the paralyzed upper chamber, leading to a shake-up in its leadership.
It was on May 26 that the minority bloc, led by Senator Vicente ‘Tito’ Sotto III, walked out to avoid forming a quorum while deliberating on the online voting rule backed by the majority, led by Cayetano.
As a result, the majority skipped sessions on Monday, June 1, and Tuesday, June 2, to maintain the status quo, which rendered the upper chamber inutile because the minority could not reach a quorum to do official business.
However, Escudero’s attendance on Wednesday allowed Sotto’s group to reach a quorum of 12, elect Senator Sherwin ‘Win’ Gatchalian as Senate president pro tempore and assign new heads of key committees.
The new majority bloc’s legal basis in saying it had a quorum was a Supreme Court (SC) case 77 years ago.
In 1949, a landmark Supreme Court (SC) ruling was triggered by the actions of then-Senate President Jose Avelino and his allies during a Senate session, who deliberately ignored then-senator Lorenzo Tañada to prevent him from delivering a privilege speech against Avelino himself during the session on February 21, 1949.
Senator Pablo Angeles David, one of Avelino’s allies, moved for the session’s adjournment even before Tañada could deliver his speech, and after a while, Avelino banged the gavel and walked out of the session hall with his companions while the rest of the senators remained.
A total of 10 senators left, while 12 remained. Then-senator Tomas Confesor was in the United States, while Senator Vicente Sotto (current Senator Sotto’s grandfather) was ill and confined in the hospital.
Then-Senate president pro tempore Melencio Arranz proceeded with the session after he was urged to do so by the 12 senators who remained. He then suggested to then-Senator Mariano Cuenco to preside over the session. The present senators unanimously voted for Arranz’s suggestion.
Tañada was able to deliver his privilege speech during this session. Later, then-senator Prospero Sanidad introduced Senate Resolution No. 67, which sought to declare the Senate presidency seat vacant and designated Cuenco as Senate president.
The 12 present senators unanimously approved the motion. Cuenco took his oath as the 4th Senate President. Then-President Elpidio Quirino recognized Cuenco as acting Senate President on February 22.
In the meantime, Escudero clarified that his attendance last Wednesday was not an indication that he has taken sides in the Senate conflict.
“I am taking a stand for the Senate. My allegiance is not to any faction, personality, group or alliance. This is not about loyalty, betrayal, or choosing one group over the other—this is about duty,” the senator pointed out.
In the Supreme Court’s 1949 ruling, it explained that the justices were unanimous in believing that the session led by Arranz was a continuation of the morning session presided over by Avelino. The Court said the walkout of the 10 senators cannot prevent the 12 other senators from passing a resolution.
Under Article VI, Section 16(2) of the 1987 Constitution, it is stated that a “majority of each House shall constitute a quorum to do business.”
The SC said 12 senators constitute a majority of the Senate of 23 senators (only Confesor was not included; Sotto was still counted). It explained that the wording “majority of each House” does not mean “all” the members. It cited the Missouri Pac. vs. Kansas case, which said that even a majority of all the members constitute “the House.”
“There is a difference between a majority of ‘the House.’ The latter requiring less number than the first. Therefore, an absolute majority (12) of all the members of the Senate, less one (23), constitutes a constitutional majority of the Senate for a quorum,” the SC cited.
In the issue of Gatchalian’s election, actions were deemed valid, like in the Cuenco case and Malacañan, which acknowledged the new Senate President’s election.
“What happened in the Senate was in accordance with law and the rule of law. The Palace recognizes and respects the new majority’s decision and the leadership of acting Senate President Sherwin Gatchalian,” Palace press officer and Presidential Communications Office undersecretary Clarissa ‘Claire’ Castro-Seechung noted.
ia/xf
