
SUPREME COURT EN BANC HIT WITH EXPLOSIVE OSG COMMENT VS. BATO OVER ICC WARRANT
By Benjamin Cuaresma
MANILA, Philippines — The Philippine government, through the Office of the Solicitor General (OSG), launched one of its strongest legal attacks yet against Ronald Dela Rosa, telling the Supreme Court of the Philippines that the former police chief cannot evade accountability while demanding the protection of the very laws that thousands of alleged drug war victims never received.
In a blistering Comment filed before the Supreme Court En Banc, government lawyers argued that Dela Rosa has no authority to determine when the law should or should not apply to him, especially amid the enforcement of an arrest warrant issued by the International Criminal Court (ICC).
The filing stemmed from Dela Rosa’s urgent motions seeking to block any cooperation by Philippine authorities with the ICC warrant issued against him in connection with the Duterte administration’s bloody anti-drug campaign.
The OSG painted a devastating picture of a sitting senator who allegedly resurfaced only when politically necessary.
According to the filing, Dela Rosa disappeared from public view amid reports of an impending ICC arrest warrant, only to suddenly appear at the Senate on May 11, 2026 — just in time to cast what was described as a decisive vote installing Alan Peter Cayetano as Senate President.
The timing of his return fueled controversy, as it coincided with the Senate’s looming impeachment proceedings against Vice President Sara Duterte.
Government lawyers noted that shortly after the vote, Dela Rosa was placed under “protective custody” by the Senate leadership. Hours later, amid lockdowns, chaos, and reports of gunfire inside the Senate compound, he once again vanished from public view.
The OSG argued that such acts mock democratic institutions and erode the rule of law.
At the center of the government’s Comment was a grim reminder of the thousands killed during the Duterte administration’s war on drugs.
The OSG traced Dela Rosa’s rise from Davao police chief to national PNP chief under Rodrigo Roa Duterte, highlighting his role in implementing Oplan Double Barrel and Tokhang.
The filing cited both official and independent estimates placing drug war deaths from several thousands to as high as 30,000.
Government lawyers stressed that countless victims never received warrants, hearings, or due process before being killed.
One of the document’s most striking lines stated:
“Their deaths were too often reduced to a single phrase: ‘nanlaban.’”
The OSG contrasted those deaths with Dela Rosa’s current demands for judicial review, constitutional protection, and legal remedies.
The government also revisited the ICC’s findings on the Duterte drug war.
According to the OSG:
- the ICC found reasonable grounds to investigate killings tied to the anti-drug campaign;
- Dela Rosa was identified as a possible “co-perpetrator” alongside Duterte;
- and the ICC warrant linked him to alleged crimes against humanity involving civilian deaths from 2011 to 2019.
The filing emphasized that ICC chambers had already characterized the killings as part of a “widespread and systematic attack against civilians.”
The OSG accused Dela Rosa of trying to use the Supreme Court case as a sweeping legal shield against possible arrest.
Government lawyers criticized his requests seeking:
- protection from ICC-related arrest,
- court intervention against government cooperation,
- access to sensitive executive records,
- and even the conversion of the case into a habeas corpus petition if arrested.
The government argued that these requests stretched far beyond the original petition and violated established procedural rules.
The filing further warned that several documents demanded by Dela Rosa involved diplomatic communications, international law enforcement coordination, and matters covered by executive privilege.
Perhaps the most emotionally charged section of the Comment came near its conclusion.
The OSG warned the Supreme Court En Banc that granting extraordinary protection to Dela Rosa while thousands of drug war victims remain dead would deepen the public’s distrust in justice.
The filing delivered this haunting line:
“The protections of the law are strongest for the powerful, and weakest for those who are now dead.”
With that, the government urged the Supreme Court En Banc to reject Dela Rosa’s motions and allow lawful processes concerning the ICC warrant to proceed.
ia/xf
