
The halls of the Sandiganbayan recently echoed with the explosive testimony of former Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) Undersecretary Roberto Bernardo, who detailed a staggering ₱130 million “balato” (share) scheme. While the figures are headline-grabbing, a closer look at the testimony reveals a foundation built more on hearsay than hard evidence—raising serious questions about the credibility of a witness who appears to be narrating events he did not actually witness.
A Case Built on ‘He-Said, She-Said’
At the heart of the prosecution’s case regarding the MIMAROPA region is ₱30 million that Bernardo claims to have received in annual ₱10-million installments from 2023 to 2025. However, by his own admission on the witness stand, Bernardo did not personally see the alleged source, former Representative Zaldy Co, handle or hand over any funds.
Instead, he testified that the money was delivered in sealed paper bags by an aide and a driver—individuals who supposedly told him the cash came from Co via then-Regional Director Gerald Pacanan.
In legal terms, this is the very definition of hearsay. Bernardo is testifying not to what he saw, but to what others told him they saw or did. Without direct material evidence or first-hand observation of the transaction between the alleged mastermind and the delivery, the testimony becomes a dangerous game of “pass the message” played in a court of law.
The Credibility Gap
Beyond the hearsay nature of his claims, Bernardo’s credibility as a “state witness” is under heavy scrutiny.
- The “Most Guilty” Question: Critics and legal observers have noted the “unusual” nature of his role. Bernardo admitted to accepting millions in what he termed “tokens of gratitude,” yet claimed he was “not privy” to the details of the transactions or any specific instructions to ignore project deficiencies. This creates a paradox: he was high-ranking enough to receive the spoils of corruption, but supposedly too detached to know how the corruption actually worked.
- A Pattern of Selective Memory: During questioning, Associate Justice Sarah Jane Fernandez pointed out that it was “unusual” for a high-ranking official to receive such large sums through a subordinate’s staff without direct contact. His defense—that he accepted the money out of “fear”—rings hollow for a veteran official of his stature.
- Past Denials and Contradictions: Bernardo’s history of allegations is increasingly viewed as a “well-orchestrated plan” to divert attention from real perpetrators, according to targets of his previous testimonies like Senator Chiz Escudero. Other figures he has implicated have filed counter-suits, labeling his claims as “defamatory insinuations” lacking any material backing.
Conclusion
The Sandiganbayan must tread carefully. A conviction cannot rest on the shaky ground of a witness who merely “understood” the money to be a gift based on the word of a driver or an aide. If the prosecution cannot bridge the gap between Bernardo’s hearsay and actual material proof, this landmark corruption case risks collapsing into a mere “sarswela”—a theatrical display of accusations that fails the ultimate test of justice. Credibility is earned through consistency and fact, not through convenient admissions of guilt that serve only to secure one’s own immunity.
(Nexus News, Views & Features)
ia/xf
