
By Benjamin Cuaresma
MANILA — Supreme Court Senior Associate Justice Marvic M.V.F. Leonen has urged lawyers and arbitrators to look beyond contracts and legal arguments, stressing that dispute resolution must consider the people and communities affected by their decisions.
Speaking at the Philippine Dispute Resolution Center, Inc. (PDRC) 30th anniversary conference on November 16, 2026, Leonen said conflicts are not merely legal cases to be won or lost but human relationships strained by unmet expectations.
“A conflict is not yet a case, and it is certainly not a file. It is a relationship under strain,” he said, emphasizing that every dispute carries a history and involves people whose circumstances deserve consideration.
Drawing from his experience as a government peace negotiator during talks with the Moro Islamic Liberation Front, Leonen recalled how opposing positions on the organization of a police force in the Bangsamoro were reconciled through carefully negotiated language.
He said the experience demonstrated the importance of understanding what parties actually need rather than focusing solely on what they demand.
Leonen also described disputes as opportunities to address circumstances and realities that parties may have overlooked when their agreements were originally made.
He cautioned, however, against allowing faster dispute resolution to compromise meaningful deliberation.
“Speed should shorten the delay, never the interval,” he said, distinguishing unnecessary procedural delays from the time needed to understand the parties and their positions.
The Senior Associate Justice also explained that judicial authority comes from the Constitution and the law, while an arbitrator’s authority rests on the consent of the parties.
An arbitral tribunal, he stressed, cannot exercise authority over individuals who did not agree to the proceedings or independently compel compliance.
Leonen further warned that arbitration decisions can affect people beyond those directly involved in the proceedings, including individuals who never appear before the tribunal but ultimately bear the consequences.
“The parties may close the door of the hearing room, but no contract can shut out the people who will live with what is decided inside it,” he said.
The November 16 conference, themed “PDRC at 30: Leading Philippine ADR into the Future,” marked the organization’s 30th anniversary and brought together members of the legal profession, Judiciary, government, business sector, and local and international dispute resolution institutions.
IA/XF
