
By Benjamin Cuaresma
MANILA — The Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) is examining whether sensitive operational information may have been compromised after Chinese naval and coast guard vessels moved unusually far from Ayungin Shoal to intercept a Philippine rotation and resupply mission.
AFP West Philippine Sea spokesperson Rear Adm. Roy Vincent Trinidad said the military was conducting an after-action review of the September 24 rotation and resupply (Rore) mission to troops aboard the grounded BRP Sierra Madre.
The mission was suspended after Philippine vessels encountered an unusually strong Chinese maritime presence much farther from the shoal than in previous operations.
Asked directly whether the AFP was investigating a possible leak of information about the mission, Trinidad said the military was “checking all the possibilities.”
He cautioned against drawing conclusions before the review is completed, stressing that the AFP routinely conducts after-action assessments following military operations, regardless of whether they succeed or are aborted.
What caught the military’s attention was the distance at which Chinese vessels were first detected.
Trinidad said Philippine forces had previously been able to approach to within about 28 kilometers of Ayungin Shoal before encountering a significant Chinese presence.
During the September 24 mission, however, Chinese People’s Liberation Army Navy and China Coast Guard vessels were detected roughly 111 kilometers, or about 60 nautical miles, from the shoal.
The AFP said three PLA Navy vessels—including two Houbei-class missile boats—and five China Coast Guard vessels were monitored during the operation.
As the Philippine convoy continued toward Ayungin, a Chinese naval vessel reportedly issued a radio warning that it would take “compulsory measures.”
Chinese vessels subsequently closed the distance to the Philippine convoy, reaching approximately 19 kilometers, 15 kilometers and 3.7 kilometers, before coming within less than 1.9 kilometers.
Trinidad declined to speculate on why the Chinese forces had positioned themselves so far from the shoal.
The AFP spokesperson said the military’s review covers possible vulnerabilities involving communications, documents, personnel and physical security.
These protocols are intended to prevent operational information from being compromised before or during missions.
Trinidad said investigators would examine all possibilities before determining what may have led to the unusually early presence of Chinese vessels.
He also declined to say whether the deployment indicated that China had prior knowledge of the Philippine mission.
The September 24 operation involved civilian vessel MV Lapu-Lapu, accompanied by three Philippine Navy and Philippine Coast Guard support vessels.
Trinidad said several factors contributed to the decision by the AFP Western Command chief to suspend the mission, including rough seas, the proximity of Chinese vessels and concerns involving the Lapu-Lapu’s engine performance.
He clarified, however, that the vessel’s engine had not broken down.
The decision was described as a judgment call intended to prevent the situation from escalating and to allow the resupply operation to be rescheduled.
The aborted operation broke a string of 15 incident-free Rore missions conducted since Manila and Beijing reached a provisional understanding on the conduct of resupply operations to the BRP Sierra Madre in July 2024, according to the Department of Foreign Affairs.
The arrangement followed a series of confrontations between Philippine and Chinese vessels during earlier missions to the military outpost.
The AFP has not announced when the next attempt to resupply the troops aboard the BRP Sierra Madre will take place.
For now, military officials are focused on determining why Chinese vessels were able to position themselves so far from Ayungin Shoal during the latest operation—and whether any Philippine operational information was compromised.
ia/xf
