
By Benjamin F.CUARESMA
MANILA — The International Criminal Court has rejected a bid by former president Rodrigo Duterte’s defense team to impose additional expert verification requirements on digital evidence submitted in his case.
In a seven-page ruling dated Sept. 26, Trial Chamber III turned down the defense request to add an “expert verification” field to the ICC’s E-Court Protocol for open-source and user-generated evidence.
The chamber said the proposed amendment did not fit the evidentiary framework it had established, under which the defense is primarily responsible for identifying and raising concerns about individual pieces of evidence presented by the prosecution.
According to the chamber, requiring the prosecution to prepare additional verification material for every such submission would effectively shift that responsibility before the defense had analyzed the evidence and identified specific issues concerning its relevance or admissibility.
Duterte’s lead defense lawyer, Peter Haynes, had sought the additional safeguard, arguing that the case was unfolding in an online environment saturated with misinformation and what he described as “fake news.”
Haynes warned that the volume of potentially unreliable material could overwhelm the evidentiary record and raised concerns over the authenticity, relevance and reliability of digital material that could be presented to the court.
The prosecution opposed the request, calling it unreasonable, unnecessary and inconsistent with judicial efficiency.
Acting ICC prosecutor Mame Mandiaye Niang argued that open-source and user-generated evidence encompass a wide range of materials and should not automatically require expert verification.
Instead, Niang said the need for an expert report should be determined on a case-by-case basis by the party submitting the evidence, which carries the burden of establishing its relevance and probative value while assessing any potential prejudicial effect.
The chamber nevertheless approved a separate prosecution request to add a URL metadata field for every open-source or user-generated item submitted as evidence.
The additional field will allow the parties to identify the specific URL or link associated with the material at the time it was captured, providing a means of tracing the digital source of the evidence.
The ruling leaves the existing evidentiary framework in place while giving parties a more direct way to identify the online origins of open-source material introduced in Duterte’s case.
ia/xf
