
By Benjamin Cuaresma
MANILA — Former House Speaker and Leyte 1st District Rep. Martin Romualdez has moved to secure his freedom, asking the Sandiganbayan to grant him bail while challenging what his lawyers described as critical weaknesses in the prosecution’s evidence in the P7.4-billion plunder case against him.
Romualdez, who is detained at the Quezon City Jail Male Dormitory, filed the petition before the Sandiganbayan Third Division, arguing that the prosecution failed to present evidence of guilt sufficient to justify his continued detention for plunder.
“The right to bail is a fundamental right guaranteed by the Constitution… Where evidence of guilt is not strong, the accused must be admitted to bail,” the petition said.
Romualdez pleaded not guilty during his September 16 arraignment.
The prosecution has accused Romualdez, fugitive former House Committee on Appropriations chairperson Zaldy Co and other co-accused of amassing billions of pesos through an alleged system of “commitments” involving infrastructure contractors.
Romualdez’s defense, however, argued that the prosecution has failed to establish a direct connection between the former speaker and the alleged collections.
According to the petition, the prosecution’s narrative largely rests on the alleged acts of other individuals, with the link to Romualdez supplied by inference rather than evidence demonstrating his own participation.
“At every point where the narrative passes from the conduct of others to accused Romualdez, the connection is supplied by inference from what precedes it rather than by a proven circumstance of accused Romualdez’s own conduct,” the petition said.
The defense also directly challenged testimony involving former security aides who allegedly transported and delivered suitcases containing cash.
Of the P7.4 billion in alleged cash deliveries cited by the Office of the Ombudsman, the petition said P4.79 billion was attributed to three former security aides—Belnard Tube, Rosebert Waupan and Benny Bulontate.
The three have since executed sworn statements retracting their earlier allegations and claimed they were pressured into signing pre-drafted testimonies, according to Romualdez’s petition.
The defense said 14 of the 21 delivery entries relied on the accounts of the three former security personnel.
“These are not general denials. They are contradictions, by named persons, of specific accounts of specific deliveries, and they create conflicts that the Resolution did not resolve and that this Honorable Court must weigh,” the petition said.
One of the transactions cited involved Waupan’s alleged delivery of 50 suitcases containing P1.1 billion in December 2023. The petition said Waupan later withdrew the allegation along with Bulontate and Cecilio Larroder.
Another alleged transaction involved 17 large suitcases containing P850 million in mid-2024, which the defense said was contradicted by retractions and statements from J. Bunagan, Larroder, Bulontate, Tube and a person identified as “Loma.”
The defense argued that evidence showing the movement of luggage does not establish what was inside the suitcases, the amount allegedly carried, the supposed unlawful source of the money or Romualdez’s knowing receipt of it.
“The delivery evidence may establish the transportation of luggage on certain occasions; It is not proof evident of the contents, the amount, the unlawful source, or accused Romualdez’s knowing receipt,” the petition said.
Romualdez’s lawyers also challenged evidence from former DPWH Undersecretary Roberto Bernardo and former DPWH Bulacan First District Engineer Henry Alcantara, arguing that their accounts described alleged dealings involving Co, other DPWH officials and contractors but did not establish Romualdez’s participation, knowledge, receipt, control or benefit.
The defense further argued that alleged discrepancies in Romualdez’s Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth did not independently prove his participation in the alleged conspiracy.
Corporate records and financial transactions involving third parties and alleged shell corporations were likewise challenged, with the defense saying these failed to establish beneficial ownership or funding connected to Romualdez.
The Ombudsman, meanwhile, has said it would present both the original statements and the subsequent retractions of the former bodyguards as evidence against the lawmaker.
Romualdez’s camp also argued that he is not a flight risk, citing the active Hold Departure Order against him, his medical conditions requiring continuing care and his voluntary submission to the court’s authority after the arrest warrant was issued.
The bail petition now places the strength and reliability of the prosecution’s evidence at the center of the former speaker’s bid to obtain provisional liberty while the plunder case proceeds.
ia/xf
