
By Benjamin Cuaresma
MANILA, Philippines — The Supreme Court has formally recognized electronic service of notices of dishonor in cases involving the Bouncing Checks Law, or Batas Pambansa Blg. 22, while imposing safeguards to ensure that such service can be proven in court.
The Supreme Court En Banc made the clarification in affirming the conviction of spouses Arnel and Marivic Carlos on six counts of violating BP 22 after checks they issued to Tire Star Inc. for car tires were dishonored because the account had been closed.
The spouses argued that they should be acquitted because they were not properly served with notices of dishonor.
The Court rejected the claim, ruling that an issuer cannot defeat a BP 22 case simply by refusing to receive a notice or denying that it was received.
Under BP 22, an issuer has five banking days from receipt of the notice of dishonor to pay the amount due. Failure to do so creates a presumption that the issuer knew there were insufficient funds or credit when the check was issued.
Personal service remains the preferred method. A notice may be delivered directly to the issuer or to an authorized representative at a business office. If service at the office is unsuccessful, it may be left at the issuer’s residence with an adult resident between 8 a.m. and 6 p.m.
The person serving the notice must execute an affidavit detailing when, where and how service was made. Photographs or video may also be used when practicable, subject to authentication in court.
If personal service is not practicable, registered mail—or ordinary mail where registry service is unavailable—may be used, with supporting postal records and an affidavit explaining the failed personal-service attempt.
The Court also recognized email, Viber, Facebook Messenger and similar platforms as valid means of electronic service, provided the email address or account can be reliably linked to the issuer.
Where electronic service follows an unsuccessful personal-service attempt, it must be sent within 24 hours of the final attempt and must identify the dates and circumstances of those attempts.
Screenshots, messages, delivery or read receipts and chat histories should be preserved as evidence.
The Court stressed that merely denying receipt is insufficient to defeat electronic service. An issuer challenging service must show that it was physically impossible to have received the notice at the claimed time and place.
Bank-generated text messages or emails informing customers that a check was dishonored may corroborate the case but cannot substitute for the notice of dishonor required under BP 22.
In the Carlos case, a Tire Star messenger testified that he personally attempted to serve the notices at the spouses’ office. They refused to receive them and instructed an employee to sign for them.
The Metropolitan Trial Court, Regional Trial Court and Court of Appeals all found the spouses guilty.
The Supreme Court found that they failed to effectively challenge the messenger’s affidavit of service or establish that they could not have been at their office when service was attempted.
The spouses were fined a total of P609,972.58, with subsidiary imprisonment in case of nonpayment, and ordered to pay Tire Star the same amount plus interest.
In a concurring opinion, Senior Associate Justice Marvic M.V.F. Leonen agreed that electronic service should be recognized as a primary mode of communication, consistent with modern technology and the Judiciary’s digital reforms.
But he also urged the Court to reconsider its ruling in Lozano v. Hon. Martinez, which upheld BP 22 against a constitutional challenge.
Leonen questioned whether criminal punishment under BP 22 remains justified by a serious social or economic problem, warning that courts could effectively become instruments for collecting private debts.
The ruling thus settles an increasingly important procedural question while reopening a larger debate over the continuing role of criminal sanctions in dishonored-check cases.
ia/xf
