
By Benjamin Cuaresma
MANILA, Philippines — A social media post by Senator Pia Cayetano has drawn criticism from the House prosecution panel, with its spokesperson warning that the senator-judge’s public remarks could cast doubt on her impartiality in the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte.
Lanao del Sur Rep. Zia Alonto Adiong said senator-judges must refrain from making statements that may create the impression they have already formed conclusions before all evidence has been presented in court.
The concern arose after Cayetano uploaded on Facebook an edited one-minute video featuring Akbayan Rep. Chel Diokno discussing the prosecution’s request to subpoena Duterte’s bank, tax, and Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) records in support of allegations that the Vice President failed to accurately declare her assets.
The Senate impeachment court has since approved the prosecution’s request for the issuance of subpoenas covering several of Duterte’s financial records.
Adiong said the more controversial aspect of Cayetano’s post was its accompanying caption, which read in Filipino: “Nagbabakasakali lang? Walang mga ebidensya pero nag-aakusa na!” (“Just taking chances? No evidence but already making accusations?”).
According to Adiong, such a statement could be interpreted as a judgment on the merits of a case that remains under trial.
“A senator-judge must first hear the entire case and carefully evaluate all the evidence before arriving at any conclusion,” Adiong said.
He also warned that the post could raise concerns under the sub judice principle, which discourages public comments that may influence or appear to prejudge pending judicial or quasi-judicial proceedings.
“The issue is not about restricting freedom of speech,” Adiong explained. “It is about preserving public confidence that every senator-judge remains fair, neutral, and open-minded throughout the impeachment process.”
Rep. Chel Diokno likewise criticized the edited video, saying it removed the context of his explanation regarding the prosecution’s request for financial records.
Diokno stressed that the subpoena request was not a “fishing expedition,” maintaining that investigators had already found probable cause based on AMLC records allegedly involving billions of pesos that passed through the accounts of Duterte and her husband, lawyer Manases Carpio.
“We are not merely hoping to find evidence,” Diokno said. “There is already sufficient basis contained in the AMLC records.”
The impeachment complaint against Duterte includes allegations of culpable violation of the Constitution, betrayal of public trust, unexplained wealth, the alleged misuse of P612.5 million in confidential funds, and grave threats against President Ferdinand Marcos Jr., First Lady Liza Araneta-Marcos, and former Speaker Martin Romualdez.
As part of its investigation, the Senate impeachment court authorized subpoenas for the bank and financial records of Duterte, Carpio, 19 companies allegedly linked to them, and Carpio’s law partnership. However, it denied requests covering foreign currency deposits and records of two additional companies, citing insufficient evidence connecting them to the Vice President.
Adiong emphasized that senator-judges occupy a unique constitutional role and must avoid any action that could undermine public trust in the fairness of the proceedings.
“The public’s confidence in the impeachment process depends on the assurance that every senator-judge will decide solely on the evidence presented before the court,” he said.
The impeachment trial continues amid heightened political interest, with Duterte remaining one of the leading figures in early surveys for the 2028 presidential election despite the ongoing proceedings.
Under the Constitution, conviction requires the affirmative votes of at least 16 of the Senate’s 24 members. A conviction would remove Duterte from office and permanently disqualify her from holding any public office in the future.
ia/xf
