
By Benjamin Cuaresma
MANILA — The impeachment court on Tuesday ruled that an NBI witness may testify only on the existence and contents of Vice President Sara Duterte’s controversial online statements, but not on the truth of the allegations contained in them, marking a significant evidentiary ruling during the ongoing impeachment trial.
The issue arose during the cross-examination of NBI Regional Director Jeremy Lotoc, who was questioned about portions of Duterte’s Nov. 23, 2024 livestream that became the subject of the bureau’s investigation.
The witness was first asked whether the NBI investigated Duterte’s claim that threats had been made against her life while she was inside Malacañang.
Lotoc acknowledged that, at the time the livestream was being broadcast, the bureau had not yet begun any investigation into the alleged threats.
He explained that the NBI only initiated its probe after the video circulated widely on social media later that day, prompting investigators to secure and authenticate the complete recording before proceeding with the investigation.
Questioning later shifted to another segment of the livestream in which Duterte criticized House Speaker Martin Romualdez and his alleged activities involving the distribution of government funds.
The witness was repeatedly asked whether he could personally confirm the truth of those assertions.
The prosecution objected, arguing that the questioning sought to elicit testimony beyond the witness’s personal knowledge.
The impeachment court sustained the objection, ruling that the NBI official was not competent to testify on the truthfulness of the Vice President’s allegations because he was not a firsthand witness to the events she described.
“The witness is incompetent to testify as to the truth of the matter stated by the Vice President. He can only testify as to the fact that those statements were made… given that he only investigated and was not there,” the court ruled.
Following the ruling, the defense argued that investigators without personal knowledge cannot establish the factual accuracy of statements made during the livestream.
The prosecution disputed that interpretation, prompting the court to direct both parties to move forward with the cross-examination.
The proceedings then shifted to another portion of Duterte’s livestream concerning the Office of the President’s confidential funds and former House leadership, with additional video clips and transcripts presented before the witness for further questioning.
The impeachment trial resumes with both sides expected to continue debating the admissibility and evidentiary value of statements made during the Vice President’s livestream, as well as the extent to which government investigators may testify about them.
ia/xf
