
By Benjamin Cuaresma
MANILA, Philippines — The National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) had no choice but to investigate the alleged threats made against President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. because the law expressly requires it to do so, according to Integrated Bar of the Philippines (IBP) National President Atty. Allan G. Panolong.
Speaking in an exclusive interview, Panolong explained that the NBI’s role is not discretionary whenever statements or acts may constitute a criminal offense, particularly when they involve threats against the country’s highest official.
“The NBI is mandated by law to conduct an investigation whenever there are allegations that may constitute a crime. It cannot simply ignore a complaint or information involving possible criminal liability,” Panolong said.
Addressing arguments raised by the defense, the IBP chief clarified that, under Philippine criminal law, the actual execution of a threat is not an essential element of the offense of grave threats.
“One of the elements of the crime is the making of the threat itself. It is not necessary that the threatened act is eventually carried out. Whether or not the threat materializes is immaterial in determining the existence of the offense,” he explained.
Panolong also dismissed the contention that prosecutors must first establish that the alleged threat was capable of being carried out before charges may prosper.
He pointed out that the issue before investigators is whether the statements made satisfy the legal elements defined under the Revised Penal Code, not whether the threatened act was eventually committed.
The veteran lawyer likewise noted that admissions made during the proceedings—including acknowledgments that investigators were unable to prove certain factual allegations—do not automatically negate criminal liability if the essential elements of the offense have otherwise been established through competent evidence.
According to Panolong, such matters are properly weighed by the courts during trial, where both the prosecution and the defense are afforded the opportunity to present their respective evidence.
He emphasized that criminal investigations are intended to determine probable cause and should not be mistaken for a determination of guilt.
“The purpose of the investigation is to determine whether sufficient basis exists to file charges. The final determination of guilt or innocence rests solely with the courts,” he said.
Panolong stressed that respecting due process means allowing investigative agencies to perform their statutory functions while ensuring that the rights of all parties are protected throughout the judicial process.
The interview came amid continuing public interest in the NBI’s investigation into the alleged threats directed at President Marcos, with legal experts closely examining the application of the country’s criminal laws on grave threats and related offenses.
ia/xf
