
By Benjamin Cuaresma
MANILA — The Senate Impeachment Court on Monday deferred action on the prosecution’s request to move up the testimony of National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) Director Melvin Matibag after senator-judges and the defense panel raised objections over procedure and due process.
The request was presented by House public prosecutor and Iloilo Rep. Lorenz Defensor, who asked the court to allow Matibag to testify on Tuesday, July 14, instead of his original schedule. According to Defensor, the NBI chief is set to leave for a regional summit on transnational crime involving the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and the Royal Thai Police.
Defensor said the prosecution hoped to hear Matibag’s testimony immediately after the appearance of NBI Regional Director Jeremy Lotoc before resuming the sequence of witnesses previously submitted to the court.
Presiding Officer Francis Escudero withheld an immediate ruling and directed the prosecution to submit Matibag’s written request and supporting documents, with copies to be furnished to the defense.
The postponement allowed the prosecution to proceed instead with the testimony of Lotoc, one of the investigators who handled the case involving Vice President Sara Duterte’s alleged threats against top government officials.
Senator-judge Alan Peter Cayetano questioned the request, saying allowing a government official to alter the witness schedule because of another official engagement could set an undesirable precedent.
He pointed out that government agencies have deputy officials who can attend international events when agency heads are unavailable, adding that senator-judges themselves had already postponed important commitments to prioritize the impeachment proceedings.
Cayetano stressed that accommodating last-minute schedule changes could undermine the orderly conduct of the trial.
Escudero also reminded the prosecution that Matibag was not included in the list of witnesses scheduled for the current week.
He recalled that during an earlier hearing, Defensor himself had informed the impeachment court that the prosecution would first present Jeremy Lotoc, Undersecretary Zuleika Lopez, and Capt. Belinda Bello.
Because of that representation, Escudero said no subpoena had been issued for Matibag’s appearance during the second week of the trial.
The defense panel opposed the prosecution’s request, arguing that moving Matibag’s testimony forward would violate the five-day notice rule previously agreed upon by both parties.
Defense lawyer Mark Vinluan said the last-minute adjustment would deprive the respondent of adequate time to prepare for cross-examination and review the evidence linked to the witness.
He maintained that both parties had relied on the agreed schedule in preparing their respective cases.
Senate President Sherwin Gatchalian supported the objections, noting that senator-judges also devote considerable time to studying the evidence and preparing questions for every scheduled witness.
He said unexpected changes to the witness lineup could affect the court’s preparedness since members would have limited time to examine supporting documents before testimony begins.
The prosecution intends to present Matibag in connection with Article IV of the Articles of Impeachment, which accuses Vice President Duterte of issuing threats against President Ferdinand Marcos Jr., First Lady Liza Araneta-Marcos, and former House Speaker Martin Romualdez.
The allegations stem from an online press briefing on Nov. 23, 2024, during which Duterte allegedly claimed she had arranged for an assassin to target the three officials if harm befell her.
The controversial remarks were made amid tensions following the detention of her former chief-of-staff, Undersecretary Zuleika Lopez, during a House inquiry into the alleged misuse of confidential funds.
With the issue still unresolved, the impeachment court is expected to decide later whether Matibag’s testimony can be advanced or whether the original witness schedule will remain in effect.
ia/xf
